The Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom
Friday, February 26, 2010

If you've got any pies on you, you better keep an eye on 'em. P.B. Winterbottom is so desperate for them that even time is not a boundary for this short little Mario-as-evil-henchman-who-will-tie-you-to-railroad-tracks type fella. Just look at that 'stache...
The Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom
You might already know him. Some call him the biggest pie thief the land has ever seen. A thief of not only of the present but also the past. Sometimes he goes by the name P.B. Winterbottom, sometimes Winterbritches, and once in a while, Winterbum. Regardless, his mission remains the same - to claim all the pie across the land. This mischievous little fellow certainly has eyes bigger than his stomach and many misadventures to keep you busy for hours on end.
When first news of this new XBLA game was released, the lively ragtime music and 1920's-esque art style were the first of things to catch my attention. Taking inspiration from silent films and old time cinema this wonderful journey throughout space-time is definitely not one to be missed. The story follows P.B. Winterbottom, a man so obsessed with pie that he will do whatever it takes to steal all the morsels he can get his grubby little hands on. The game is a platformer in the vein of Braid, but instead of finding keys to open doors, the goal is to get all the pies scattered around each level. Sometimes you'll have to get them in a certain order, sometimes only your clones can get pies, and always you'll have to put on your thinking cap. Even after you complete the main adventure, there is still much time to be spent tackling the challenge levels, trying to go for the lowest time or using the fewest amount of clones.
Although this game is being compared to other xbla titles like Braid, it still manages to stand out and offer up a completely different experience. It is so challenging that at some points I had to collaborate with fellow WRS staff members to complete a puzzle and move on to the next stage. Some might be off put by the difficulty of some of the puzzles but I feel that it is what makes up for the game being so short. Towards the end of the game the puzzles get even harder, requiring you to think in ways you never would have before. Don't take that the wrong way; unless you're a super genius and have a heavily developed sense of spatial reasoning, some of these puzzles will definitely take time. Throughout the adventures, or misadventures I should say, P.B. Winterbottom retains a kooky and whimsical feel unlike the heavy intellectual nature of Braid. That's not to say that this game is any easier, but just different in approach. There is more than one way to solve each puzzle and while the story remains quite linear, it moves along at a great pace and gets increasingly more difficult as the end of the game draws near.
Basically what it comes down to is, this game is amazing. What's not to love about the unique and quirky art style or the lighthearted soundtrack that accompanies your adventures through space-time? The puzzles are hard, even seemingly impossible at times but with enough patience and brain power, they are in fact very rewarding upon completion. This yet again just goes to show that a big budget and blockbuster scale aren't required to make a good game. P.B. Winterbottom remains one of the best games out there on the marketplace. Thanks to developers The Odd Gentlemen, that smile I usually get on my face when I see pie may not just be because I enjoy baked goods as much as P.B., but because I have thought of Winterbottom and the whimsical world that fills a little piece of my pie, umm, I mean heart.